I have to give it to Katy on this one.

Ciara, Katy was too extra

Yeah Katy was too extra with it..so i give it 2 Ciara

I GIVE IT TO KATY ALSO…CIARA STILL CANT SMILE…

I say Ciara, b/c Katy’s dress looks cheap.

Cute Ciara.

i’m going with katy. i love the way that girl dresses…

Katy took it! I love it w/ the dress.

i thought katy’s was black cause of the way her skin blended with the pattern
anihoo, i think both rocked it nicely in different ways

ciara been wearing a lot of black and whie recently. i read a post bout suttin few weeks back bout her being part of a cult & the black and white had suttin 2 do with it. startin to wonder now… just sayin not gonna participate in some long debate

katy. it looks like a cute halloween outfit. ciara is BLAND.

ciara hands down!
katy doesnt match an it looks a mess…ciara is on point classy an cute an it matches her whole tone!
katy looks like a stripper!

CIARA!

Just because someone wears black often doesn’t mean they’re in ‘the’ or ‘a’ cult ..

–

I chose neither BUT if I HAD to choose - I’d choose Katy!

@10

KATY PERRY IS WEARING BLACK TOO AND ALSO WEARS IT OFTEN SO WHY DIDN’T YOU MENTION HER MAYBE BEING IN THE “CULT” AS WELL?

katy …
& i’m one of ciara’ s biggest fans
i remember this night
i think she was performing or something
that big white tunic is giving me 3x hanes white tee
and it’s not matching ANYTHING on those shoes
atleast katy had a motive .

i’ve never heard of ciara being in a cult
she’s always talking about giving God glory
a lot of ppl say “im lucky” she always says “im blessed”

Sorry but Ciara you win this hands DOWN. Katy looks whack, she’s too extra with all those nasty red bows and and that horrible dress. She looks a hot mess. Ciara is plain but at least she manages to be classy, Katy just looks like a San Francisco tranny whore!

WOW,I SHOCKED BUT CIARA ACTUALLY LOOKS BETTER IN THEM.

CIARA WIN!
@NUMBER 12
I AGREE!
WITH EVERYTHING YOU SAID

CIARA ROCKED THOSE BETTER! DUHHHH! KEEP IT UP HATERS =]

Ciara looks WAY better.

ciara! all day!
my bish got it!

I SEE THE RIHANNA EFFECT ON KATY. SHE’S BE DRESSING ALOT EDGY THESE DAYS LOOKING GOOD THOUGH

i love those boots on ciara
katy perry i love you to death
but um…
she looks like a bratz doll

and i’ve noticed that ciara’s been
wearing alot of black lately too
but i don’t think its beacuse if
this whole “cult” thing…
thats retarded
if anything people should be
checking if jay z or rihanna is
a part of that shit…
fuckin devil worshipers…

My Wife Ciara Obviously!
Katy……ERRRRRRR!!

ciara hands down

Lately I haven’t been rockin with Ciara but she has this one…CLEARLY.

I think she looks amazing in these boots! But the name “circus” is so right, for the name of them

I Say Neither.
It’s A Ugly Ass Pair Of Shoes No Matter Who It’s On.

Katy hands down…Ciara messed up with the cutout shoes and leggings underneath, that defeats the purpose of the cutout style…

@@ #4:

AND U CALL WHAT KATY IS DOING WITH HER FACE A SMILE??????????

CIARA….

BECAUSE WITH HER FIT, IT WAS ALL IN THE STRATEGY…AND SHE FOLLOWED THE FASHION RULES WHEN IT COMES TO OVER EXAGGERATED SHOES….

“ALWAYS GO MODEST AND MORE RESERVED WITH YOUR OTHER ITEMS OF CLOTHING WHEN THE SHOES ARE LOUD AND VIBRANT. THIS DIRECTS THE ATTENTION MORE TOWARD THE SHOES.”

KATY’S FIT WAS LOUD ALL OVER AND THAT’S WHEN IT BECOMES TOO MUCH. WHEN THE SHOES ARE LOUD ENOUGH, LESS IS MORE WHEN IT COMES TO THE TOP HALF.

They both look cute in this

DEFINITELY Ciara… Katy looks awful.

Katy looks like a japanese porn star… #justsayin

I have to say my lady CiCi rocked those boots!!

Why Christian ! ! ! They were lovely as a ankle boot (bootie). I like neither.