Whitney has always outdone Mariah in the looks dept. both in beauty and fashion.

neither, WH’s dress ot to glittery for those boots and I hate when women wear all black with back boots, so NEITHER lol

^ agreed

yeah whiteny has always been prettier. mariah has the better shape though. fashion-wise whitney is better but they both look like messes here. i said neither

neither,both look bad!!

mariah rocked it better imo

Both ladies are legends and beautiful but I’m not feeling either one on this one.

mariaaaaaaaaaaahhhhh

can we get a better look at the actual boot?

I agree w/ #1 but Mariah definitely looks better in this..

The shoes w/ Whitney’s get up don’t go at all.

@ 9. Click on the link provided in the actual post….

both look gud to me

I don’t think Mariah is a cute woman and it’s showing more and more, with age.

Whitney was S-T-U-N-N-I-N-G in her day and still looks beautiful (most of the time).

Neither. Whitney missed the mark this time and Mariah has never had any style.

Obviously Mariah (if I had to choose).
The boots do not look good with Whitney’s outfit.

Mariah rocked it. Whitney’s dress is too formal for those boots.

This shoud be “Who Rock’d The Hair Better” instead of the boots.

Ummmm…how about neither.

I guess if i had to choose, Imma go with Mariah

ARE YOU SERIOUS???….. HOTT BOOTS… BUT NOT ON THESE 2 OL’ HEADS…LOVE THEM BOTH, BUT THEY LOOKING LIKE 1980′S IN 2009 FASHION… NICE TRY THO SWEET CAKES… MAYBE YALL SHOULD PASS THOSE DOWN TO RHI RHI AND AMBER ROSE… LET THEM WALK IT OUT IN THOSE BOOTS…

PEACE CL….

Whitney’s dress is better I guess. Mariah’s dress looks like something she always wears. lol The boots though look good on both of them.

BTW, what happened to Tianna? I just noticed she wasn’t around anymore.

WHITNEY LOOKIN LIKE A 6 YR OLD CHILD WHO DRESSED HERSELF FOR A SHOW OR SUMTHIN…. LOL

I’M ABOUT 2 GO LOOK 4 THOSE BOOTS ON THE NET RIGHT NOW THEY ARE HOT!!!! (THE BOOTS)

Those two are crufts and need to leave them looks to the young gal dem!

Mariah wins this,her legs are more shapely and defined than Whitney,and complements the boots better.Whitney`s legs are skinny,and have no shape or definition to them, ,they are straight up and down ,like stilts, She looks like one of the Harlem Globetrotters with those skinny legs,the only thing missing is the basketball.

i love the look went for w| those boots!

Whitney Houston legs looks a mess. Those years of drugs have aged her horribly!yuck . Mimi wins ,hands down.
@ 20 I remember Tianna got married awhile back and kinda faded from then on ,IDK.

They both look nice. Love the boots.

i have to go with Whitney because she is prettier

Are you people Crazy? take off Whitney’s wig, make up, lashes and she’s a hoodrat from Newark.

Mariah Carey has beautiful features.

Not to mention her CD is HOT

i’m gonna choose neither because mariah looks a hot shit and with whitney, the shoes clashes with the entire outfit…

Neither. Mariah can’t dress & Whitney’s dress looks…..not right w/ the boots

Mariah is a copy cat as usual. She gets a big FAT FAIL!

Mariah looks like she got her dress from Stitches.
$13.99 on the sale rack. SMH.

love them both but i perferred whitneys look a lil more than mariahs…hers was a lil too plain like she coulda been wearin some ole regular ass black books

Nothing beats “the little black dress”.

Whitney looks like she’s about to perform…Mariah on the other hand looks like she’s on the corner sellings to tricks at Hunts Point!

Whitney looks better than Mariah Carey… yea the hell right! Whitney still looks like she’s on crack in that pick. She looks all old. Mariah looks lke she’s 30 instead of 40. Whitney’s legs are all skinny and aged. Mariah’s legs are so nice and fill out that dress perfectly. I agree, it is an ugly dress, but Mariah definitely rocked this one. Plus, her boots are HOT!

I said Whitney just cause……

But Mariah may always receive the dick anytime she likes…..

Whitney- she’s rockin it and staying classy for her age- folks she wore it for her video ‘million dollar bill’ that is why it’s sparkly. Mariah just looks like a round da way girl waiting for a guy to pick her up.

Whitney looks beautiful.

Sorry but neither. Really cute boots but they didnt work them…

Both of them are cute in their own way, anyway the boots are hot
*only if I had the money*

NO, the question is - Which ones are paid for… Hmm, I’ll go with Mariah here.

I DONT LIKE THE BOOTS ON NOE OF THEM OLD BITCHES!

mariah rock those boots better but both do look sorry in this picture